The Best Sweet and Tangy Amish Macaroni Salad Recipe: A Pennsylvania Dutch Classic

No picnic, potluck, or backyard barbecue is truly complete without a generous bowl of this sweet and creamy Amish Macaroni Salad! This beloved Pennsylvania Dutch recipe stands out from ordinary macaroni salads with its uniquely tangy dressing, crafted from a perfect blend of mayonnaise, yellow mustard, apple cider vinegar, and a hint of smoked paprika. Forget the store-bought versions – once you taste this homemade gem, you’ll agree it’s better than anything you’ll find at the deli counter.

Growing up in Pennsylvania, the Amish community and their distinctive culture are never far from people’s minds. I remember traveling in Ireland back in 2007, and the immediate association people made when I mentioned I was from Pennsylvania was often with the Amish. Even at a Kate Voegele concert, the opening act expressed genuine amazement at the thought of seeing Amish people. While the western side of the state, particularly around Pittsburgh, isn’t typically considered “Amish country” (that honor largely goes to the Lancaster area), I have encountered Pennsylvania Dutch communities near my college and even at local attractions like the zoo carousel. These encounters always remind me of the rich heritage that influences so much of our local culture and, perhaps most notably, our cuisine.

If there’s one thing I’m incredibly grateful for from the Pennsylvania Dutch culinary tradition, it’s their incredible food. Beyond their famed baked goods and hearty comfort meals, their side dishes are truly exceptional. Their Amish Potato Salad is a personal favorite, but today, we’re diving into another star of the show: the incredibly delicious and unique Amish Macaroni Salad. Many people might wonder, “Amish macaroni salad? What exactly sets it apart?”

For years, my introduction to this style of macaroni salad came from the Walmart deli – yes, you read that right, the Walmart deli! Whether it’s a staple in all Walmarts or primarily in Pennsylvania stores, their version was a delightful approximation of the traditional Amish recipe. It became a beloved, nostalgic flavor. Now, I’m thrilled to share my own homemade Amish macaroni salad recipe, which is surprisingly simple to prepare. The process involves just a few straightforward steps: cooking the pasta to perfection, whisking together the vibrant dressing, tossing all the ingredients, and chilling to allow the flavors to meld beautifully. Since macaroni salad often yields a large quantity, this recipe focuses on a convenient small batch, perfect for about 4 servings, making it ideal for smaller gatherings or meal prepping throughout the week.

What Makes Amish Macaroni Salad Unique?

At first glance, Amish macaroni salad might seem similar to other creamy pasta salads. Both typically feature cooked macaroni, often hard-boiled eggs, and a rich, mayonnaise-based dressing. However, the key distinction, and what truly makes Amish macaroni salad stand out, lies squarely in its signature dressing. Unlike many conventional macaroni salads that lean purely savory or slightly sweet, the Amish version boasts a distinctly sweet and tangy profile. This unique balance is achieved through the generous addition of yellow mustard and vinegar, which cut through the richness of the mayonnaise, creating a harmonious and incredibly addictive flavor that keeps you coming back for more. The subtle smokiness from paprika further elevates this classic, adding a layer of depth that many other macaroni salads lack. It’s this carefully balanced combination of sweet, tangy, and savory notes that defines the Pennsylvania Dutch style and makes it so universally loved.

Essential Ingredients for Authentic Amish Macaroni Salad

Creating this delicious Amish Macaroni Salad requires a thoughtful selection of ingredients, each playing a crucial role in achieving its signature flavor and texture. Here’s a breakdown of what you’ll need and why:

• Elbow Macaroni: The classic choice for macaroni salad! Its curved shape is perfect for cradling the creamy dressing, ensuring every bite is flavorful. While elbow macaroni is traditional, other small pasta shapes like ditalini or even farfalle (bow-tie pasta) can work if you’re looking for a slight variation in texture, though the classic elbow is highly recommended.
• Mayonnaise: This forms the creamy base of our dressing. For the richest flavor and best consistency, always opt for real, full-fat mayonnaise. If you’re considering using Miracle Whip, please refer to our note below on how to adjust the recipe, as it has a different sweetness and texture profile.
• Granulated Sugar: A crucial component that delivers the characteristic sweetness of Amish macaroni salad. The amount can be adjusted to your preference, but it’s essential for balancing the tartness. Keep in mind that the sweetness of your mayonnaise or any substitute like Miracle Whip will influence how much sugar is needed. Taste and adjust as you go!
• Yellow Mustard: This is a defining ingredient, providing that unmistakable tangy kick and vibrant yellow hue. The acidity of yellow mustard is key; it helps to brighten the dressing and cut through the richness of the mayonnaise, creating a more complex and appealing flavor.
• White Distilled Vinegar: Another acidic powerhouse that contributes significantly to the salad’s tangy profile. Vinegar balances the sweetness and richness, adding a refreshing tartness that makes the salad so invigorating. Apple cider vinegar can also be used for a slightly fruitier tang.
• Smoked Paprika: While not always present in every regional variation, a touch of smoked paprika adds a wonderful depth of flavor and a subtle smoky warmth. It also lends a beautiful, appealing color to the dressing, making the salad even more enticing.
• Kosher Salt: Essential for seasoning both the pasta water and the dressing. Salt enhances all the other flavors, ensuring the salad isn’t bland. Adjust to taste, remembering that flavors deepen as the salad chills.
• Hard-Boiled Eggs: These add a lovely creamy texture and a boost of protein, making the salad more satisfying. They are a traditional component in many creamy pasta salads. If you need a refresher, learn how to make perfect hard-boiled eggs.
• Carrot: Grated carrots bring a natural sweetness, a vibrant pop of color, and a pleasant crunch that contrasts beautifully with the soft pasta.
• Bell Pepper: While many traditional macaroni salads often feature celery for crunch, I personally prefer the milder flavor and crisp texture of bell pepper. Green bell pepper is a classic choice, but red or yellow can also add a nice sweetness and visual appeal. This substitution maintains the desired crunch without the strong flavor of celery, which isn’t to everyone’s liking.
• Onion: Finely diced white or yellow onion adds a subtle pungency and a bit of a savory bite, which helps to further balance the sweetness and richness of the dressing. For a milder flavor, you can soak the diced onion in cold water for 10-15 minutes, then drain well, before adding it to the salad.

Can I Substitute Miracle Whip for Mayonnaise in Amish Macaroni Salad?

This is a common question, and while you *can* substitute Miracle Whip, it’s important to understand the differences. Miracle Whip is technically a “salad dressing” rather than mayonnaise, as it contains less vegetable oil and a higher sugar content, along with a distinct blend of spices. My recipe has been carefully developed using real mayonnaise, which provides a richer, less sweet, and more savory base flavor.

If you choose to use Miracle Whip, be aware that its inherent sweetness will likely mean you’ll need to significantly reduce the granulated sugar called for in the recipe. I recommend tasting the dressing as you mix it and adjusting the sugar (and possibly vinegar or mustard) gradually until it achieves the desired sweet and tangy balance that defines Amish macaroni salad. Be prepared for a slightly different flavor profile overall, but with careful adjustment, it can still yield a delicious result.

Step-by-Step Guide: How to Make the Best Amish Macaroni Salad

Making this classic Amish Macaroni Salad is incredibly straightforward, even for novice cooks. Follow these steps for a perfectly creamy and flavorful result:

1. Cook the Macaroni: Begin by bringing a large pot of water to a rolling boil. Once the water is vigorously boiling, add a generous amount of salt – this is crucial for flavoring the pasta itself, not just the water. Then, add your elbow macaroni and cook according to the package directions until it’s al dente (firm to the bite). Al dente pasta holds its shape better in salads and prevents it from becoming mushy.
2. Rinse and Dry the Pasta: Once cooked, drain the macaroni thoroughly in a colander. This next step is vital for pasta salad: rinse the macaroni under cold running water. This immediately stops the cooking process and, importantly, washes away excess starch, which helps prevent the pasta from sticking together. After rinsing, allow the pasta to drain and dry completely. You can gently toss it or spread it out on a clean kitchen towel to speed up the drying process. Excess water will dilute your dressing.
3. Prepare the Dressing: While the pasta is cooking and cooling, prepare your creamy, tangy dressing. In a medium bowl, whisk together the mayonnaise, granulated sugar, yellow mustard, white distilled vinegar, smoked paprika, and kosher salt until smooth and well combined. Taste and adjust seasonings if necessary; this is where you can fine-tune the sweet and tangy balance to your liking.
4. Prep the Vegetables and Eggs: Chop your hard-boiled eggs, grate the carrot, and finely dice the green bell pepper (or celery) and onion. Having all your components ready makes assembly quick and easy. This recipe is also a fantastic way to utilize any leftover hard-boiled eggs you might have from holiday meals, like your Easter dinner for two.
5. Combine and Chill: In a large mixing bowl, add the completely dry, cooked macaroni. Stir in the chopped hard-boiled eggs, grated carrot, diced bell pepper, and diced onion. Finally, pour the prepared dressing over the macaroni and vegetables. Toss everything gently but thoroughly until all the ingredients are evenly coated with the creamy dressing.

Once everything is combined, cover the bowl tightly and refrigerate the macaroni salad for at least 1 hour. However, for the absolute best flavor development, allowing it to chill for a full 24 hours is highly recommended. This extended chilling time allows the ingredients to meld and the dressing to fully permeate the pasta, creating a more cohesive and delicious salad. Store any leftover macaroni salad in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 5 days, ensuring it remains fresh and flavorful.

Expert Tips for Perfect Macaroni Salad Every Time

How to Keep Pasta Salad from Sticking Together

A common pitfall in pasta salads is pasta that clumps together, creating an unappetizing texture. When you cook pasta for hot dishes, you typically don’t rinse it because you want the starch to help sauces adhere and maintain temperature. However, for cold pasta salads, the approach is different. It’s absolutely essential to rinse your cooked macaroni under cold water immediately after draining. This achieves two crucial things:

• Stops the Cooking Process: Cold water instantly halts the pasta from cooking further, preventing it from becoming overcooked and mushy, which is undesirable in a cold salad.
• Removes Excess Starch: The primary reason for rinsing is to wash away the sticky surface starches. If left unrinsed, these starches cause the pasta strands to adhere to each other, forming unappealing clumps. Rinsing ensures your macaroni remains perfectly separate and tender.

After rinsing, shake the colander well and let the pasta air dry for a few minutes, or even gently spread it on a clean baking sheet lined with paper towels to ensure it’s as dry as possible before mixing with the dressing.

How to Keep Amish Macaroni Salad from Drying Out

There’s nothing more disappointing than a pasta salad that starts off creamy but quickly dries out as the pasta absorbs all the dressing. To combat this common issue and ensure your Amish macaroni salad remains lusciously creamy from the first scoop to the last, here are a few key strategies:

• Ensure Pasta is Completely Dry: As mentioned above, after rinsing, make sure your pasta is thoroughly dry. Any residual water on the noodles will prevent the dressing from properly coating them and will dilute the dressing, making it more prone to being absorbed too quickly.
• The Two-Stage Dressing Method: For a foolproof creamy macaroni salad, consider using a technique similar to the one I employ for my Caesar Pasta Salad. Toss the cooked and dried pasta with only about half to two-thirds of the dressing before chilling. This initial coating provides flavor and moisture while the salad develops. Right before you’re ready to serve, stir in the remaining dressing. This guarantees a fresh burst of creaminess and ensures the salad doesn’t appear dry, even after extended chilling. While not strictly necessary, it’s a great insurance policy for ultimate creaminess.
• Store in an Airtight Container: Always store your leftover Amish macaroni salad in an airtight container in the refrigerator. This minimizes exposure to air, which can cause the dressing to evaporate or the pasta to dry out. A tightly sealed container helps maintain moisture and freshness for longer.
• Add a Splash of Liquid (If Needed): If, upon serving, you find your chilled salad has absorbed more dressing than desired, don’t fret! You can easily revive its creaminess by stirring in a tablespoon or two of additional mayonnaise, a splash of milk, or even a little extra vinegar to loosen it up and restore its luscious texture.

What Can I Serve With This Creamy Macaroni Salad?

Amish macaroni salad is the quintessential side dish for any casual gathering, from summer picnics to backyard cookouts and family potlucks. Its sweet and tangy profile pairs beautifully with a wide array of main courses. Getting ready to plan your next outdoor feast? Here are some fantastic recipes that complement this macaroni salad perfectly:

• Italian Potato Salad: It’s a classic pairing! Nearly every picnic I’ve attended features both macaroni and potato salad. This particular recipe offers a delightful alternative as it’s an eggless potato salad made without mayonnaise, providing a contrasting texture and flavor to the creamy macaroni salad.
• Avocado Burgers: A fresh and flavorful burger inspired by California cuisine. The cool, creamy avocado offers a nice contrast to the tangy macaroni salad.
• BBQ Bacon Burgers: For those who love bold flavors, these sweet and tangy cheeseburgers loaded with bacon, crispy onion rings, and savory BBQ sauce are an excellent match for the refreshing macaroni salad.
• Pesto Burgers: A lighter, more herbaceous option featuring refreshing turkey burgers with basil, mozzarella, and juicy tomatoes. Their bright flavors would be beautifully balanced by the rich macaroni salad.
• Teriyaki Turkey Burgers: A delightful sweet and savory turkey burger crowned with a slice of grilled pineapple. The tropical sweetness of the burger would harmonize wonderfully with the tangy notes of the Amish macaroni salad.

No matter what you choose to serve alongside it, this Amish Macaroni Salad is sure to be a crowd-pleaser and a staple at your next gathering!

Amish Macaroni Salad

Yield:
4 servings

Prep Time:
20 minutes

Cook Time:
10 minutes

Chill Time:
1 hour

Total Time:
1 hour 30 minutes

No picnic is complete without this sweet and creamy Amish Macaroni Salad! This Pennsylvanian Dutch recipe is better than Walmart’s Amish Macaroni Salad with a tangy dressing made of mayonnaise, mustard, vinegar, and smoked paprika.

Ingredients

• 1/2 pound (8 ounces) uncooked elbow macaroni
• 1 cup mayonnaise* (see Note about using Miracle Whip)
• 2 tablespoons granulated sugar
• 2 tablespoons yellow mustard
• 2 tablespoons white distilled vinegar
• 1 teaspoon smoked paprika
• 1/8 teaspoon kosher salt
• 2 hard boiled eggs, chopped
• 1 large carrot, peeled and grated
• 1/4 cup diced green bell pepper or celery
• 1/4 cup diced white or yellow onion

Instructions

1. Bring a large pot of water to a boil. Once boiling, add a big handful of salt then add macaroni. Cook as directed on the package until al dente, about 10 minutes. Drain into a colander and rinse with cold water. Let dry completely.
2. Meanwhile, in a medium bowl, whisk together the mayonnaise, sugar, mustard, vinegar, paprika, and salt.
3. Add the cooked macaroni to a large bowl. Stir in the eggs, carrots, green pepper, onion, and dressing.
4. Cover and refrigerate at least 1 hour or until cold (24 hours is preferred to allow the flavors to develop).

   Refrigerate leftovers for up to 5 days.

Notes

• This recipe has been developed with mayonnaise, which has a different taste than Miracle Whip. If you do substitute Miracle Whip, you may need to adjust the other ingredients accordingly.
• Enjoyed this recipe? Check out my Amish Potato Salad and Caesar Pasta Salad.

Did you make this recipe?

Let me know what you think! Rate the recipe above, leave a comment below, and/or share a photo on Instagram using #HITKrecipes

Originally published July 11, 2009