Peach Pie Yogurt Pops: Your Ultimate No-Bake Summer Dessert

Imagine the delightful flavor of a freshly baked peach pie, but in a refreshing, frozen form, ready to enjoy without ever turning on your oven. That’s exactly what these Peach Pie Yogurt Pops offer! They are the quintessential summer treat, transforming seasonal peaches into a creamy, fruit-filled popsicle that tastes just like your favorite dessert, all conveniently served on a stick. It’s truly the perfect way to embrace and celebrate the abundance of fresh peaches during the warmer months.

The Annual Peach Picking Adventure and a Culinary Twist

Every August, a cherished tradition brings me immense joy: heading out with my dad to pick peaches directly from the orchard. This year, the anticipation was just as high, and the day itself started off beautifully. We were greeted by a picturesque sky filled with fluffy clouds, promising a perfect, rain-free day for our outdoor adventure. The air was fresh, and the excitement of harvesting our own fruit was palpable.

However, despite the idyllic setting, this year’s peach picking experience brought a few unexpected challenges. Our initial enthusiasm quickly turned into a bit of disappointment. First, the price per pound was notably higher than in previous years, which was a bit of a shock. While it was still likely more economical than purchasing 10 pounds of peaches from a grocery store, it certainly wasn’t the bargain we had hoped for.

Second, and perhaps more crucially for my recipe development plans, the peaches we were directed to pick were far from the soft, ripe specimens ideal for immediate use. We followed the orchard staff’s guidance precisely, choosing from the designated trees, so it wasn’t a matter of simply picking from the wrong section. Had we been aware of the crop’s condition – specifically how firm the peaches were – we would have certainly postponed our visit. Unfortunately, at this particular orchard, payment is required upfront before entering the fields, leaving us with no option but to proceed.

Adding a touch of unexpected drama to our outing, a persistent bee managed to find its way into our bag of freshly picked peaches. Naturally, I entrusted Dad with the delicate task of safely removing our buzzing companion – a moment that provided a small, humorous, and slightly sticky interlude in our day!

Adapting to Unexpected Delays in the Kitchen

This unexpected firmness of the peaches presented a significant hurdle for my culinary schedule. In the world of recipe development, where timelines are often tight and ingredients need to be ready precisely when you need them, having to wait for fruit to ripen can throw a major wrench into well-laid plans. It meant a considerable adjustment to my week’s schedule, requiring me to reshuffle tasks and hope that all necessary preparations could still be completed on time.

Fortunately, I managed to navigate these unforeseen circumstances without missing any crucial deadlines. I’m quite adept at problem-solving in the kitchen, and I’m confident I would have found a workaround even if a deadline had been jeopardized. As luck would have it, among the many firm peaches, I did manage to unearth a few softer ones that were ready for immediate use. These precious few peaches were destined for the very first recipe on my revised schedule: these delightful Peach Pie Yogurt Pops.

These popsicles draw inspiration from my incredibly popular watermelon yogurt popsicles, but with a special addition of ingredients specifically chosen to evoke the warm, comforting flavors of a classic peach pie. The idea of “frozen pie on the go” – a convenient, no-bake dessert that captures all the essence of its baked counterpart – sounded absolutely perfect to me, and I knew it would be a hit!

Tips for Ripening Peaches and Achieving Perfect Pops

If you ever find yourself in a similar predicament, with peaches that are a bit too firm for your liking, don’t despair! There’s a simple, effective trick to speed up the ripening process. Just place your peaches in a brown paper bag along with a ripe banana. Both fruits naturally release ethylene gas, a plant hormone that aids in ripening. By containing these gases within the bag, you create an environment that encourages the peaches to soften much more quickly than if they were left out on the counter. Check them daily, and you’ll soon have perfectly ripe, juicy peaches ready for your recipes.

Choosing Your Popsicle Molds (or Making Your Own!)

While I typically use a dedicated popsicle mold, for these Peach Pie Yogurt Pops, I often opt for a more readily available and equally effective solution: 5-ounce plastic cups, commonly known as Dixie cups. These are fantastic for homemade popsicles and offer a convenient way to make individual servings without needing specialized equipment. To hold your wooden popsicle sticks in place while the pops freeze, simply cover the tops of the cups with foil and then make a small incision in the center to insert the stick. If you prefer smaller, kid-friendly portions, 3-ounce cups work just as wonderfully.

For the smoothest possible texture in your peach popsicles, it’s essential to peel your peaches. The skin, while edible, can sometimes create a slightly fuzzy or less refined mouthfeel in frozen treats. Peeling ensures a silky, delightful consistency that truly lets the peach flavor shine. If you need a quick and easy method for peeling peaches, be sure to check out my detailed step-by-step photos and guide on How To Peel Peaches. It’s a game-changer for any peach-based recipe!

Crafting the Perfect Peach Pie Yogurt Pop: Ingredients and Method

The magic of these popsicles lies in their simple yet carefully balanced ingredients, designed to emulate the classic flavors of peach pie. Here’s a closer look at what goes into these delightful treats and how to prepare them:

Ingredient Spotlight:

Fresh Peaches: The star of the show! Aim for ripe, fragrant peaches. Peeling them ensures a smooth texture, free from any fibrous skin.
Greek Yogurt: This provides the creamy base, a lovely tang, and a protein boost. Its thick consistency also helps create a wonderfully rich popsicle.
Brown Sugar: Unlike white sugar, brown sugar contributes a deeper, caramel-like sweetness that perfectly mimics the warm notes found in baked fruit pies.
Lemon Juice: A splash of lemon juice is crucial. It brightens the peach flavor, prevents the pops from being overly sweet, and helps preserve the vibrant color of the fruit.
Ground Cinnamon: This spice is the heart of the “pie” flavor. Its warm, aromatic notes pair perfectly with peaches.
Vanilla Extract: A classic enhancer that rounds out the flavors and adds a comforting sweetness.
Almond Extract: This is a secret weapon for many stone fruit desserts! A tiny bit of almond extract enhances the natural flavors of peaches, giving them a more complex, bakery-like taste.
Milk (Optional): If your peaches aren’t particularly juicy, a small amount of milk can help the mixture blend into a perfectly smooth consistency.
Graham Cracker Crumbs: These are the “crust” element! Rolling the frozen pops in crumbs before serving adds a delightful texture and completes the peach pie illusion.

Equipment You May Need (affiliate links):

Peach Pie Yogurt Pops

Yield:
4-5 pops

Prep Time:
15 minutes

Total Time:
15 minutes

Ingredients

3 cups peeled and chopped peaches (roughly 3-4 peaches – see How To Peel Peaches.)
1/2 cup Greek yogurt
1/4 cup packed brown sugar
1 tablespoon lemon juice
1/4 teaspoon ground cinnamon
1/4 teaspoon vanilla extract
1/4 teaspoon almond extract
1/4 cup milk (optional)
2 tablespoons graham cracker crumbs

Instructions

In a blender, combine the peeled and chopped peaches, creamy Greek yogurt, rich brown sugar, tangy lemon juice, aromatic ground cinnamon, fragrant vanilla extract, and a hint of almond extract. Blend thoroughly for 1-2 minutes until the mixture is perfectly smooth and velvety. If your peaches lack natural juiciness, feel free to add up to 1/4 cup of milk to achieve the desired smooth consistency. Once blended, pour the mixture through a fine mesh strainer into a large bowl, ensuring any remaining solids or fibers are discarded, leaving you with a silky-smooth peach base.
Carefully pour the vibrant peach mixture into your chosen 5-ounce plastic cups or a traditional popsicle mold. If using cups, cover each top securely with aluminum foil, then gently pierce a small hole in the center of the foil. This hole will serve as a stable anchor for inserting your wooden popsicle sticks. Place the filled cups or mold into the freezer and allow them to freeze until completely firm, ideally overnight, to ensure they hold their shape perfectly. Before serving, for that authentic “pie crust” flavor and texture, briefly remove the pops from the freezer, unwrap them, and gently roll them in graham cracker crumbs. Enjoy your refreshing taste of summer pie!

Did you make this recipe?

Let me know what you think! Rate the recipe above, leave a comment below, and/or share a photo on Instagram using #HITKrecipes

Why You’ll Love These Peach Pie Yogurt Pops

These Peach Pie Yogurt Pops are more than just a refreshing treat; they’re a symphony of flavors and textures designed to delight. Here’s why they’re sure to become a summer staple in your home:

No-Bake Bliss: Beat the summer heat by skipping the oven entirely. All the deliciousness of pie, without the warmth of baking.
Healthy & Delicious: Packed with fresh fruit and protein-rich Greek yogurt, these pops are a wholesome alternative to many store-bought frozen desserts. You control the ingredients, so you know exactly what you’re eating.
Authentic Pie Flavor: The thoughtful blend of brown sugar, cinnamon, vanilla, and almond extract truly captures the essence of a classic peach pie, transforming a simple popsicle into a sophisticated dessert.
Easy to Make: With just a blender and a few simple steps, you can whip up a batch of these pops in no time. Perfect for busy weeknights or impromptu gatherings.
Versatile & Customizable: While the recipe is fantastic as is, you can experiment with different types of yogurt (dairy-free options work too!) or even add a pinch of nutmeg for a slightly different spice profile.
Kid-Friendly: Kids absolutely adore popsicles, and these are a fantastic way to get them to enjoy more fruit. The “pie” flavor makes them extra special.

Beyond the Recipe: Making the Most of Peach Season

Peach season is a fleeting, glorious time, and these yogurt pops are just one fantastic way to savor its bounty. Consider making a double batch to have on hand for quick snacks or unexpected guests. They’re also an excellent make-ahead dessert for barbecues and picnics. The bright, sweet-tart flavor of the peaches, combined with the creamy yogurt and warming spices, creates a truly unforgettable experience.

Whether you’re dealing with an abundance of freshly picked peaches or simply craving a taste of summer, these Peach Pie Yogurt Pops are an absolute must-try. They embody everything wonderful about the season – fresh fruit, cool treats, and effortless enjoyment. Don’t let another summer pass without experiencing this delightful frozen take on a classic comfort food.

More Popsicle Recipes for Your Summer Indulgence

If you loved these Peach Pie Yogurt Pops, be sure to explore more of our refreshing popsicle creations:

Margarita Popsicles: A fun, adult-friendly twist on a classic cocktail, perfect for happy hour!
Coconut Popsicles: Transport yourself to a tropical paradise with these creamy, exotic pops.
Strawberry Popsicles: Classic, simple, and bursting with fresh strawberry flavor – a timeless favorite.
Orange Creamsicles: Relive childhood memories with this creamy, citrusy delight.
Fudgesicles: Rich, chocolatey, and wonderfully satisfying for any sweet tooth.