Soft & Chewy Pumpkin Sugar Cookies with Creamy Cinnamon Buttercream
No need to fuss with rolling pins when you’re craving the quintessential flavors of autumn! These incredibly soft and chewy Pumpkin Sugar Cookies are infused with warming pumpkin spice and generously crowned with a luscious, creamy cinnamon buttercream frosting. Simply scoop, bake, and then let your creativity shine with decoration. They’re the perfect, easy-to-make treat for a cozy fall day.

As soon as the leaves begin to hint at their changing colors and the air gets that crisp, inviting chill, my mind immediately turns to pumpkin. I simply couldn’t let another autumn pass without sharing a delightful pumpkin recipe, and these Pumpkin Sugar Cookies were the first call of the season. Frosted generously with a rich cinnamon buttercream, they embody everything wonderful about fall baking.
These cookies share a delightful softness with my popular chocolate sugar cookies and vibrant orange cookies, but with a distinctly autumnal twist that makes them utterly irresistible. The addition of real pumpkin puree and a blend of warm spices transforms a classic sugar cookie into a seasonal sensation.
I don’t know about you, but I have an undeniable soft spot for decorating sugar cookies, especially with sprinkles! Truth be told, I might just be a sprinkles hoarder. There’s something so joyful about adding a pop of color and texture to a freshly baked treat. Do you prefer the classic, elongated jimmies, or are you a fan of the tiny, crunchy nonpareils? While I admittedly love all sprinkles equally, the traditional kind often win out for their charming appearance.
However, let me be clear: I am by no means a master cookie decorator. My skills extend to simple designs, much like those on my chocolate chip cut-out cookies. You won’t find any award-winning intricate piping here, and that’s perfectly fine! The beauty of these pumpkin sugar cookies is that elaborate decoration isn’t even necessary. The dough is designed for ease – no rolling, no chilling, and no cookie cutters required. Just a simple scoop, and you’re ready to bake!
As they bake, these delightful cookies will spread ever so slightly and puff up beautifully, creating soft, pillowy centers with just a hint of a crispy edge. This unique texture makes them incredibly satisfying. Once they’ve cooled completely, the magic truly happens when you slather them with that creamy cinnamon buttercream, adding an extra layer of spice and indulgence that perfectly complements the pumpkin flavor. These cookies are guaranteed to become a fall favorite in your home.